Ordoño II of León

King of León from 914 to 924 who made the old Roman city of León the permanent seat of the Asturian monarchy, raided as far as Mérida, and fought Abd al-Rahman III to a victory at San Esteban de Gormaz and a disaster at Valdejunquera.

Overview

Ordoño II was king of León from 914 until his death in 924, and the ruler under whom the kingdom of the Asturias finished becoming the kingdom of León. He had already governed Galicia as a subordinate king from about 910; when his brother García I died childless in 914 he took the whole inheritance, and he fixed the monarchy in the city on the meseta by handing over his own palace there to be made into a cathedral.

His reign was the first in which León fought the rising power of Abd al-Rahman III as an equal and lost to it. He beat an Andalusi army at San Esteban de Gormaz in 917 and killed its commander; three years later, allied with Pamplona, he was broken at Valdejunquera and two of his bishops were carried off. His response to that defeat — arresting the Castilian counts who had not come — is the single episode later Castilian writers never forgave him.

Birth and early life

He was born about 873, the second surviving son of Alfonso III the Great, the king who pushed the Asturian frontier down to the Duero, and of his queen Jimena. No source records the birth itself; the date is inferred from his brothers and his career. He grew up in a monarchy whose centre of gravity was already sliding southwards out of the Cantabrian mountains, away from Oviedo and towards the repopulated plain.

In about 910 Alfonso III was deposed by his own sons and the kingdom was divided among them: García took León, Ordoño took Galicia, and Fruela took Asturias. Ordoño therefore ruled for four years as a king under a king, with Compostela and the Galician sees in his hands — which is why the cartulary of Santiago remembered him as a benefactor, and why his first campaigns run south-west out of Galicia towards the Tagus rather than south out of León.

Character and Personality

Almost everything said about Ordoño’s character comes from Sampiro, and Sampiro is not a neutral witness. He was a Leonese cleric who served as notary to Bermudo II and then as majordomo to Alfonso V before ending as bishop of Astorga, and he wrote his chronicle in the early eleventh century, a hundred years after Ordoño’s death, as a continuation of the Chronicle of Alfonso III covering the years 866 to 982. He was, in other words, a royal officer of the Leonese court writing the history of the dynasty that employed him, and his Ordoño is a vigorous and pious king who endowed churches and beat Muslims. The chronicle survives mainly because the Historia silense absorbed it wholesale in the early twelfth century, so even the hostile reader meets Ordoño through a court servant’s account preserved by a monastery of León.

The Andalusi sources supply the other half of the picture and they are no more disinterested. Ibn Hayyan and the anonymous chronicle of al-Nasir record the same campaigns from Córdoba’s side, and in them Ordoño is the enemy whose defeat at Valdejunquera demonstrates the caliph’s favour with God. What both traditions agree on is the behaviour rather than the temperament: a king who raided a long way from home, who bargained and allied with Pamplona, and who punished failure hard.

The episode that fixes his reputation is the seizure of the Castilian counts. Sampiro reports without embarrassment that Ordoño summoned Nuño Fernández, Fernando Ansúrez and Abolmóndar Albo to the banks of the Carrión and had them arrested for not appearing at Valdejunquera. Three centuries later, when Castile was the senior partner and needed a story about Leonese tyranny, that arrest became the founding grievance of Castilian independence and the counts became martyrs. Modern historians read it more plainly, as a king enforcing military obligation on magnates who had judged the campaign not worth their men — an ordinary act of tenth-century kingship that acquired its meaning later.

From Galicia to the throne of León

The move of the royal seat to León is often given to Ordoño alone, and that is not quite right. His brother García I was the first to hold court in the city, from about 910, and the shift out of Oviedo belongs to the division of Alfonso III’s kingdom rather than to any single decision. What Ordoño did was make it irreversible. On inheriting in 914 he did not return the court to Oviedo, and he gave up the royal palace inside the old Roman walls so that a cathedral could be built on it, which tied the monarchy’s prestige to the city permanently.

The logic was military before it was ceremonial. León stood on the meseta at the head of the repopulated Duero country, a day’s march closer to the frontier than the mountain capital, inside the walls of a legionary fortress that needed no building. A king who intended to campaign south every summer needed to live where the campaigns started. The Asturian kingdom of the mountains became the Leonese kingdom of the plain because its kings had decided to fight on the plain.

The war with Córdoba

Ordoño’s raids reached further south than any Leonese king had managed. In the years around 915 he struck into the Guadiana country, took and sacked Muslim strongholds, and extracted tribute from the governors of Mérida and Badajoz — a demonstration that the emirate of Córdoba, then still fighting its own rebels, could not protect its western provinces.

That window closed as Abd al-Rahman III consolidated his authority. On 1 and 2 September 917 an Andalusi army under Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Abda came north against the frontier fortress of San Esteban de Gormaz and Ordoño destroyed it; the commander was killed and his head set on the walls. In 918 the Leonese and the Navarrese together took Arnedo and Calahorra from the Banu Qasi.

The reckoning came on 26 July 920. Ordoño and Sancho Garcés I of Pamplona met the Andalusi army at Valdejunquera in Navarre and were beaten badly enough that the fortresses of Muez and Viguera fell afterwards and their garrisons were killed. The bishops Hermogio of Tuy and Dulcidio of Salamanca were taken prisoner. Neither king was destroyed — both were campaigning again within a few years — but the initiative on the frontier had passed to Córdoba, and it stayed there until Ordoño’s son Ramiro II broke a caliphal army at the Battle of Simancas in 939.

The killing of the Castilian counts

After Valdejunquera, Ordoño turned on the counts of the eastern march who had not brought their men. He called Nuño Fernández, Fernando Ansúrez and Abolmóndar Albo to a meeting on the river Carrión, at a place the sources call Tejares, and had them seized and carried in irons to León. Sampiro, who is the source, treats the arrest as justified discipline; some accounts have the counts executed, others released soon afterwards, and the chronicle tradition is not consistent about which.

The importance of the episode is entirely retrospective. Castile at this date was a frontier command of León, held by several counts at once at the king’s pleasure, and Ordoño was doing what a king could do to men who had failed a summons. But within two generations Fernán González had gathered those counties into one hereditary lordship, and by the thirteenth century Castilian writers had the story they needed: a Leonese king murdering Castilian nobles by treachery, and a county that owed León nothing thereafter. The arrest on the Carrión is where the legend of Castilian independence begins, a long way from anything Ordoño intended by it.